Accounting for Convertible Debt Instruments

Convertible Debt InstrumentsAccording to EY, the convertible debt market saw whipsaw action in issuances. Between 2015 and 2019, average issuance varied between $40 billion and $45 billion. However, it dropped to $22 billion in 2022 but re-accelerated to $52 billion in 2023. While the levels of issuance varied, the way this type of debt is accounted for has remained much calmer.

Defining a Convertible Bond

A convertible bond is a type of debt security that gives the investor the right to exchange the bond, at certain milestones, for a pre-determined percentage of equity in the issuing company. This investment vehicle has both equity and debt features.

Since this type of investment gives investors the potential for equity conversion into a company, the debt/bond side of it may present investors with a nominal coupon remittance or a potentially zero-coupon payment. However, there are important accounting considerations for this type of investment vehicle via generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).

IFRS

When it comes to IFRS, convertible bonds are considered blended securities because they are partially debt and partially equity. The debt piece is accounted for by discounting the principal and interest paid out to the bondholder at the company’s cost of straight debt. The following example illustrates how it’s calculated:

The business presents a 10-year, $250 million convertible bond, providing investors with a 2.5 percent coupon rate and a 9.5 percent straight cost of debt. Based on discounting these variables, the present value of the principal and coupon payments is: $182,805,096 (assuming end-of-year, annual coupons). To determine the equity proportion, we must take $250 million and subtract $182,805,096, which equals $67,194,904.

Looking at the journal entry, we have the following breakdown:

Cash: Debit $250,000,000

Convertible Debt Component – Liability = $182,805,096

Equity Component – Shareholder’s Equity = $67,194,904

Looking at the interest expense this is calculated as follows:

The 9.5 percent (straight debt cost) is multiplied by the net present value of the beginning debt liability balance of the first year ($182,805,096), which is $17,366,484.12. Since there’s a coupon payment of (2.5 percent X $250,000,000 = $6,250,000), the difference between $17,366,484.12 and $6,250,000 = $11,116,484.12 should be “accreted” to the debt liability or the debt balance.

The journal entry would be as follows:

Debit: Interest Expense $17,366,484.12

Credit: Cash $6,250,000

Credit: Accretion of Debt Discount – Liability = $11,116,484.12

Now, if at the bond’s maturity, the investor is unable to convert the bond to equity according to the terms of the convertible note, the entire $250 million bond will be paid back to the investor. The journal entry will be as follows:

Debit: Convertible Debt $250,000,000

Credit: Cash $250,000,000

If, however, the investor of the convertible bond is favorable to it being exchanged, the journal entry will be as follows:

Debit: Convertible Debt $250,000,000

Credit: Share Capital – Shareholder’s Equity = $250,000,000

This explanation assumes that convertible bonds are only able to be converted into company equity. However, if the bond is cash-settled, there are alternate considerations. It’s also assumed that the bond is issued at year’s end and makes its coupon payments once a year.

GAAP

Under generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), present standards treat it as straight debt. This accounting practice changed from GAAP’s previous treatment of bifurcating it, similar to IFRS’ current treatment.

At issuance, the journal entries are as follows:

Debit: Cash $250,000,000

Credit: Convertible Debt $250,000,000

With this accounting treatment, it’s recognized as an interest expense. Since this contrasts with IFRS, no accretion is required under GAAP. This assumes there are no additional debt issuance costs when calculating interest expenses. Therefore, assuming the same initial debt amount at par and the coupon rate for year one, it’s the rate for the debt issuance multiplied by the full debt amount ($250,000,000).

The journal entry is as follows:

Debit: Interest Expense $6,250,000

Credit: Cash $6,250,000

If the convertible debt doesn’t present a good opportunity for the investor, they’ll receive the principal back. The journal entry is as follows:

Debit: Convertible Debt $250,000,000

Credit: Cash $250,000,000

If, however, the convertible debt presents the investor with an opportunity to convert to equity, and it’s exercised, the journal entry is presented as follows:

 Debit: Convertible Debt $250,000,000

 Credit: Share Capital – Shareholder’s Equity $250,000,000

Conclusion

While these examples do not explore all the potential scenarios when accounting for convertible debt, they show what considerations accountants must keep in mind when analyzing a transaction.

Pre-Retirement Planning Guide Health Plan

Pre-Retirement Planning Guide Health PlanStep 4: Putting Together a Health Plan

Planning for healthcare in retirement is a tricky business. Some hardcore smokers live past 100, while some hardcore exercise and fitness gurus drop dead in their sixties. You just don’t know – which is why you need a plan.

Medicare

Once you turn 65, Medicare is available to most Americans. The problem is deciding what type of Medicare plan to purchase. Here is an overview:

Medicare Part A – This plan covers hospital stays, skilled nursing, hospice and some home health services. It is free for eligible beneficiaries but caps some benefit coverage and requires a deductible for each inpatient hospital stay. When a hospital stay is longer than 60 days, you’re required to pay a per-day rate – and that can add up.

Medicare Part B – This plan does charge a premium, and you have to buy it in concert with Part A. Part B covers doctor visits, preventive care, screenings, treatments, and medical equipment. It does not cover dental, vision, or hearing care and only pays for procedures deemed medically necessary. This plan also features a much lower deductible than Part A, but beneficiaries are responsible for 20 percent of covered services after the deductible.

Collectively, Parts A and B are what’s known as Original Medicare.

Medicare Part C – This plan is more commonly known as Medicare Advantage (MA). It is a paid alternative that combines coverage from Part A and B, plus offers add-on options for drug coverage, dental, vision, long-term care, etc. Plans vary significantly by insurer and may include any combination of deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance.

Medicare Part D – This plan offers coverage for prescription drugs. It charges a premium determined by your income, and deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance vary by plan. You have the option to purchase a standalone Part D plan when you enroll in Original Medicare.

Medigap – Also known as a Medicare Supplement Plan, this policy is a good idea whether you go for Original Medicare or an MA plan. That’s because it offers coverage for a lot of the gaps in those plans that generate high out-of-pocket expenses, including deductibles and coinsurance.

Long-Term Care

Among Americans who live past age 64, more than two out of three (70 percent) will at some point need long-term care. Whether you hire paid caregivers or move into a long-term care (LTC) residence, the cost of services currently averages between $60,000 and $100,000 a year in the United States. One of the biggest determinants of cost depends on whether you can get by with limited hours of help a day or need full 24-hour care. Note that for those with mobility issues (i.e., they cannot get to and from the toilet by themselves), 24-hour care is more likely.

Long-term care insurance (LTCi) can help you pay for this type of care so that you don’t deplete your savings quickly. This is especially important for couples, in which one spouse may need to enter an LTC residence while the other lives at home, with all the expenses that it entails.

The best time to buy LTC insurance is while you’re still healthy, as it is medically underwritten. The “sweet spot” is around age 55, but anytime in your mid-50s to early 60s is ideal. In most cases, policies are more expensive for women than men because women tend to live longer.

Caveats to Consider

  • Policies typically pay out a limited daily amount, which may not cover the full cost.
  • Policies typically pay out only for a limited period (e.g., 3 to 7 years)
  • A policy may have a lifetime amount cap

All this is to say that you may purchase a generous LTCi policy, but if you outlive its limits, you will need to use your own money to pay for caregiving and/or rely on Medicaid when you run out of funds.

Hybrid Insurance

The biggest risk to purchasing an LTC policy is that you may never need it. Some policies offer a form of premium return, but like most insurance policies, LTCi generally uses it or loses it. To avoid this scenario, another option is to purchase a life + LTC insurance plan – also known as a hybrid policy. It provides a certain amount of life insurance upon death. However, if you need long-term care before you pass away, the policy will allow you to tap that death benefit amount to pay for it. This allows you to use the coverage either for LTC or as a life insurance payout for your beneficiaries.

Plan For These Expenses Now

While everyone is usually thinking about how to pay for household expenses, travel excursions, or a second home in retirement – they often don’t think about a health plan. As you can see, Medicare doesn’t cover everything and those expenses can add up, especially for people who live a long time.

But if you start planning long before retirement, you can contribute to an earmarked account that builds over time and uses that money to pay for medical expenses. The Health Savings Account (HSA) requires enrollment in a high-deductible health plan, whether offered by an employer or purchased on your own. Contributions made to an HSA are tax-free (which reduces taxable income), and the funds can be invested for tax-free growth in a variety of investment options. Withdrawals are also tax-free as long as they are used to pay for eligible healthcare products and services.

Note that HSA proceeds are your money, no matter what. It differs from employer-sponsored accounts such as an HRA (health reimbursement account) or an FSA (flexible savings account) because you have only a limited time to use those funds – then they revert back to the employer. In other words, you can’t access that money once you retire.

Important Update on New Company Reporting Laws CTA – BOI

Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), Beneficial Ownership Information (BOI)On Jan. 1, 2024, the U.S. government debuted the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA). This legislation established the requirement for the majority of private companies, both big and small, to file information with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN).

As with most new laws, the initial guidance and interpretations have been both challenged and questioned. In response, FinCEN recently turned out new FAQs, which we review below.

Big Question First: To Report or Not

Reporting is generally required by all private, for-profit entities. This includes corporations, LLCs, S-Corps, etc., whenever the company was created by filing a document with the office of the Secretary of State. Entities formed under the laws of jurisdictions outside the United States are also likely subject to reporting if they are registered to do business in the United States.

To help visualize the above, you can take a look at this flowchart published on the FinCEN website.

Screenshot from FinCEN website

While the general rules seem (and are) broad in construction, there are 23 specific exemptions, including publicly traded companies, nonprofits, and certain large operating companies. The FinCEN’s Small Entity Compliance Guide checklist can help in determining if you fall under an exemption.

Now, let’s move on to more specific questions.

Who is a beneficial owner?

An individual who either directly or indirectly exercises substantial controls or owns 25 percent or more of the reporting company.

What constitutes substantial control?

There are four (separate) ways to exercise substantial control:

  • The individual is a senior officer
  • Has the authority to appoint or remove officers or a majority of directors
  • An important decision-maker (regarding strategic, business, or finance)
  • They have any other form of substantial control as per the FinCEN’s Small Entity Compliance Guide.

Who is a company applicant for a reporting company?

Another of the more perplexing questions revolves around exactly who a company applicant of a reporting company is.

First, only reporting companies created or registered on or after Jan. 1, 2024, need to concern themselves with the company applicant rules; companies formed before are exempt.

There are two possible individuals who could be considered company applicants. One is the person who directly files the documents to create and register the company. This person will always exist and be an applicant of the reporting company. In the case where there were multiple people involved in the filing or registration, the individual who primarily controlled the filing is also considered an applicant.

Thankfully, FinCEN created another handy flowchart to help navigate through this rather confusing decision.

Screenshot from FinCEN website

What about sole proprietorships?

It depends. Sole proprietorships only have to report if the entity was created by filing a document with a secretary of state or similar office. In other words, if you just start freelancing and don’t file anything with a secretary of state office, you are not subject to the reporting requirements. Basically, if you didn’t form an LLC, you don’t need to report. For example, obtaining an employer identification number, a fictitious business name, or a professional or occupational license does not subject you to the FinCEN reporting requirements.

What if my company ceased to exist before the CTA requirements went into effect?

If a company ceased to exist on or before Jan. 1, 2024, then they are NOT subject to the reporting requirements.

Do I have to report more than once?

No, you only have to file an initial report once. There is NOT an annual report. You do, however, need to amend your original filing to update pertinent changes or corrections within 30 days of their occurrence.

What happens if I don’t file a report?

Willful violation can subject one to a fine of up to $500 per day until the violation is resolved. Criminal penalties could also be imposed, resulting in up to two years imprisonment and a fine of up to $10,000.

Conclusion

The FinCEN released its guidance to clarify uncertainties around the new CTA-created reporting requirements. The goal is to ensure full and accurate compliance without undue burden on companies and individuals.